Owen & Amelia’s Battle About Abortion On ‘Gray’s Anatomy’ Was A Lengthy Time Coming


Gray’s Anatomy‘s very properly may have been sending a message to Dr. Owen Hunt with the title of its Thursday, Nov. 7 episode: “Papa Do not Preach.” When Owen and Amelia argued a few affected person’s abortion within the episode, Dr. Hunt’s views gave the impression to be largely symptomatic of some extra deeply rooted points. The surgeon let his private baggage — and a bruised ego — bleed into his skilled life to the purpose of denying this affected person her proper to well being care. The rationale for his feelings basically superseding his Hippocratic Oath: Amelia blurted out to him that she’s pregnant with Hyperlink’s child throughout a (maybe misguided) go to to Pac North. Extra on all that later.

The case on the middle of the ex spouses’ disagreement over girls’s reproductive rights concerned a single mom who ended up within the Pac North E.R. following a fall down her basement stairs. The girl was devastated by Owen’s information she’s eight weeks pregnant with a child she will neither afford, nor has the time to boost. She works two restaurant jobs and already cares for her younger son, she defined.

“So that you threw your self down the steps?” Owen scolded the lady, insinuating her fall was an reckless try and abort her being pregnant. It seems he’d jumped to an incorrect conclusion, although the affected person’s fall was not directly associated to an abortion try. With no insurance coverage, and after a number of makes an attempt to get an appointment at a clinic that supplied monetary help, the lady revealed she’d resorted to utilizing a web based recipe for a self-induced natural abortion at residence. Determined to ensure the herbs labored, she defined she’d doubled the recipe, and thus, grew to become lightheaded and misplaced her stability whereas hauling the laundry basket up and down the basement stairs.

ABC/Byron Cohen

Amelia was available as a result of Owen, to his credit score, accepted her recommendation {that a} lady could also be extra snug confiding in one other lady about one thing so deeply delicate and private. (Owen may have mainly been a poster boy for why that is the case, on this episode.) Sympathetic to the lady’s state of affairs, Amelia assured her that after Owen completed her minor stomach process, somebody from OB may carry out the abortion. The girl gave the impression to be past aid till… Enter misanthropic Owen, who abruptly snatched away her solace, inexplicably insisting they simply “give attention to the autumn accidents first” and “tackle the being pregnant” as soon as she’s out of the woods.

“Why not simply give her the assistance she’s asking for?” an incensed Amelia requested her ex, as soon as within the privateness of the hallway. Owen’s official reply, on the time: “I am a trauma surgeon, I do not order abortions.” What he actually meant, nonetheless, was that he was projecting his personal points onto the lady — regardless of having no private connection to her case in any respect.

His choice to thwart the lady’s alternative to securely abort her being pregnant is one that may majorly have an effect on her life, to not point out her well being, within the quick time period. And the way did we get right here? If Amelia had modified her thoughts about eager to have a child (over time, by the way in which), certainly he’d be doing this lady a favor by denying her well being care as a result of she may finally change her thoughts too, proper? That gave the impression to be Owen’s thought course of anyway. And there is no means Cristina’s choice to abort their child again in Season eight did not have a triggering impact right here, too.

When Amelia lastly confronted Owen once more for refusing the lady the assistance she wanted, she questioned how a lot their historical past factored into his choice. Amelia even outwardly requested if he refused the affected person an abortion as a result of she wished to assist her have one. “Is that this about me?” Amelia requested Owen. “Is that this as a result of I am pregnant, so that you suppose that girls who say they do not need infants are simply going to get up sooner or later and alter their minds?”

Owen at the least bought factors for self-awareness right here, admitting his actions had been influenced by the damage he may solely describe by invoking the previous “it is not that you just did not wish to have a child, it is that you just did not wish to have a child with me” argument. He additionally threw down the sufferer card, whining about seeing Amelia glad and having a child with one other man after she’d brought on him the ache of divorce as a result of she did not need children. Can we pause for a second to keep in mind that Owen selected to be along with his “soul mate” Teddy, aka the lady with whom he simply had a child himself? (Aspect observe: He did not have one of the best response to Teddy’s being pregnant information both.)

ABC/Byron Cohen

For no matter purpose, Amelia soothed Owen’s damage satisfaction, apologizing and assuring him that she, certainly, did not need children prior to now. (Apparently Owen does not understand that individuals can evolve?) Amelia even confessed she’d been not sure about motherhood to the purpose she’d initially thought-about having an abortion herself. By dialog’s finish, they gave the impression to be amicably on the identical web page, nonetheless, and Owen even copped to being “horrible” to his affected person and owing her an apology.

Off display screen, not every little thing can often be wrapped up in such a neat bow, nonetheless. Gray’s has actually been holding it actual so far as shining a lightweight on real-life well being care points (see Meredith taking over the insurance coverage trade), so it is price noting this storyline may additionally simply as simply be ripped from the headlines, so to talk. Another person will occupy the fictional affected person’s mattress within the subsequent episode, and there might be one other gripping story to comply with. When medical doctors behave like Owen did, in the actual world, nonetheless, the reverberations are typically a lot better.



Supply hyperlink

You might also like

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More